Restoring the Jewel of Downtown

Painting Services for the Old Northside

Restoring the Jewel of Downtown

The Old Northside is Indianapolis history at street level. Walk its blocks and you’re surrounded by the ambition of a different era—Italianate mansions, Queen Anne showpieces, and Second Empire homes built during the city’s Gilded Age. These houses weren’t designed to blend in. They were built to make a statement, and more than a century later, they still do.

From the Benjamin Harrison area to the restored homes along Delaware, Alabama, and Park Avenue, the Old Northside is a place where architecture matters. Every bracket, spindle, and cornice tells a story.

At Elite Pro Painting, we understand that painting a home in the Old Northside isn’t a cosmetic project. It’s preservation work. As a family-owned Central Indiana painting company, we approach these homes with patience, respect, and a deep appreciation for the craftsmanship that went into them.

Why Painting Homes in the Old Northside Is Different

Historic homes demand a completely different mindset. Materials behave differently. Expectations are higher. Mistakes are far more visible—and far more costly.

If you’re looking for an Old Northside exterior painting contractor, preparation and historical understanding matter more than speed.

Exterior Painting Focused on Preservation

Most Old Northside homes still contain original siding, trim, and architectural detailing.

In many cases, those surfaces have accumulated dozens of paint layers over the last century.

We begin by slowing things down.

Homes built before 1978 require lead-safe work practices, and we follow them carefully. Specialized containment, HEPA-filtered sanding, and controlled cleanup help protect your household, neighboring properties, and the surrounding soil.

Historic wood needs to be stabilized, not buried. We perform deep scraping, repair failing sections, and use primers designed to penetrate and seal older wood fibers. This creates a stable base for finish coats rather than trapping problems underneath new paint.

Color matters in the Old Northside. Modern neutrals often feel out of place here. Many exterior updates require coordination with preservation guidelines, and we help homeowners select palettes that reflect the home’s era—rich greens, warm ochres, deep reds, and complementary trim colors that highlight architectural details rather than flatten them.

Queen Anne homes, in particular, demand patience. Multiple colors, varied textures, and intricate trim packages require steady hands and a methodical approach. Crisp lines and thoughtful contrast bring these homes back to life.

An Old Northside Interior Painter Who Respects the Craft

Inside these homes, the craftsmanship continues.

Tall ceilings, plaster walls, pocket doors, carved staircases, and original millwork are common.

As an Old Northside interior painter, our goal is to preserve that character while making spaces livable.

We handle plaster repair carefully, maintaining the integrity of original walls rather than replacing them with modern shortcuts. Wood trim and paneling are treated with finishes that protect and enhance the material, whether the goal is restoration or a thoughtful update.

Large interior volumes require planning. Grand staircases, multi-story foyers, and expansive rooms demand proper access and extensive protection. Floors, fixtures, and historic features are safeguarded throughout the project.

We Want You To Know…

It’s Not Just Paint—It’s Purpose

First-place benefits for you, and meals donated to local families with every completed project.

Family-Owned & Mission-Driven

Our close-knit, family-run Indianapolis painting company stays focused on what matters most—your home, your experience, and giving back to our community with every project.

Honest Pricing. No Surprises.

From your first evaluation to the final invoice, you’ll know exactly what to expect—no bait-and-switch, no hidden costs.

Professional Painters You Can Trust

Clear communication, expert craftsmanship, and a smooth, stress-free experience from start to finish.

Why Old Northside Homeowners Choose Elite Pro Painting

Homeowners in the Old Northside care deeply about their homes—and so do we. Much of our work comes from referrals, and we understand the trust that represents.

We back our projects with a strong warranty because we believe in the durability of proper preparation and quality materials. From initial planning through final inspection, our focus is on doing the work the right way.

If you’re looking for a painting company that understands historic architecture and treats your home with the respect it deserves, we’re ready to help.

Other Neighborhoods We Serve

4.9 590 reviews ★★★★★

Trusted by Over 20,000 Indianapolis-Area Homeowners

Read Customer Reviews

    
 
 
       Posted on Google  
   
   Sean Anderson 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Flexible with my schedule and did excellent work!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Janece Jones 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Outstanding! When I decided to paint my house, I was so nervous. However, I found the right company! Everyone was professional yet friendly and approachable. Every text/call was answered and nothing happened until I was 100% comfortable. Pricing was honest and fair and the work product outstanding. Shout out to Robert and Jaime for all the hand holding!! Thank you, Elite Pro Painting! Very happy customer!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Nathan Williamson 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great service and communication!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Vickie Gandiello 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Elite Pro Painting is the best! We always knew we would use them when the time came due to interactions with the owners in the past. Their crew was extremely professional and did an excellent job for us. They went above and beyond expectations. From start to finish with Robert giving us the estimate and necessary information to the end of the project, it was a great experience. Jamie is most excellent in her job as a project manager. Marybelle, Oswaldo, and Ivan worked nonstop to get the work done. We appreciated their kindness and patience with us and our requests. We recommend them highly to anyone who needs interior or exterior painting done.
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Allison Smith 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I really cannot say enough good things about this company. They arrived promptly when they said, and had amazing communication throughout the entire process. Jamie, the project manager was incredible! I knew what to expect every step of the way and she kept checking in with me to make sure I was happy with everything. I thought the process would be a lot harder and a lot longer, but they were very efficient. Not even a piece of tape was left in my yard!  They prepped and cleaned up beautifully. 10 out of 10 would recommend to everyone!
  
 
      Posted on Google  
   
   Steve Rice 
 
 
 
 Trustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Awesome job!

Painting Services for the Old Northside

Restoring the Jewel of Downtown

Why Painting Homes in the Old Northside Is Different

Exterior Painting Focused on Preservation

Most Old Northside homes still contain original siding, trim, and architectural detailing.

An Old Northside Interior Painter Who Respects the Craft

Inside these homes, the craftsmanship continues.

We Want You To Know…

It’s Not Just Paint—It’s Purpose

First-place benefits for you, and meals donated to local families with every completed project.

Family-Owned & Mission-Driven

Honest Pricing. No Surprises.

Professional Painters You Can Trust

Why Old Northside Homeowners Choose Elite Pro Painting

Other Neighborhoods We Serve

Explore Neighborhoods

Featured Neighborhoods

Don't see your neighborhood listed?

Trusted by Over 20,000 Indianapolis-Area Homeowners

Trusted by Indianapolis. Proven by Results.

Elite Pro Painting

Elite Pro Painting Carmel

Elite Pro Painting Noblesville

Elite Pro Painting Indianapolis

Elite Pro Painting Indianapolis

Elite Pro Painting Zionsville

Get A Free Estimate